The debate surrounding Darnell Nurse has taken another turn following his offseason trade from the Edmonton Oilers to the San Jose Sharks. This time, Oilers fans are pushing back against what they see as a dramatic shift in media coverage.
The discussion began after The Hockey Writers published a story. The article questioned whether Edmonton’s defense remains strong enough to contend after Nurse’s departure.
MORE: Quinn Hughes could earn $16M-$18M AAV in new Wild contract
That prompted a response from the hockey page Bleed Oil Blue, which wrote, “For years, all we heard was that Darnell Nurse was holding the Oilers back on and off the ice. Now that he’s been traded, suddenly it’s, ‘What a huge loss. The Oilers blue line is so much worse without him.’”
The fanbase instantly rallied behind those words.
One supporter wrote, “Media is biased against the Oil. They want them to fail.”
Another fan offered a more balanced assessment, saying, “He was always a positive for the Oilers. He just didn’t live up to a $9M cap. With that said, I think Shea is a larger addition than Nurse so as a whole the defensive group is a bit better.”
A third fan compared the reaction to another recent departure. “It was the same with Skinner, everyone was shitting on the guy constantly, then the trade happened and the tone shifted by most of the same people.”
One fan wrote, “I disagree. We will be much better. He made a bunch of errors. In almost every game.”
A user shared his perspective, writing, “He needed to go. For him and the team. He wasn’t awful, but he wasn’t $9 million good either.”
A fan wrote, “Hockey world has and always will revolve around the Oilers.”
Darnell Nurse trade changes conversation around Oilers’ defense
Edmonton traded Nurse to the Sharks on July 1 after the veteran defenseman requested a move and waived his no-trade clause. The Oilers received Shakir Mukhamadullin and prospect Zack Sharp while clearing Nurse’s entire $9.25 million cap hit.
“It’s exciting for me,” Nurse said, via NHL.com. “It’s a change, a new market, a fresh start in a lot of senses. But it’s also exciting to play in the division I played in my whole career, whether Edmonton is in it or not. It’s a familiar division to me, and I’m really looking forward to playing with San Jose.”
Meanwhile, both views carry some truth. Nurse’s contract often overshadowed his overall value, making him an easy target despite consistently handling difficult defensive assignments.
MORE: Flyers linked with Connor McDavid after Leo Carlsson setback
The real question is whether Edmonton can replace those minutes. Ryan Shea is going to help in that role, but the Oilers’ blue line will ultimately be judged by results rather than changing opinions surrounding Nurse.
About the Author
