Mitch Marner delivered the most productive playoff run of his NHL career in 2026. However, the ending has reignited a narrative that followed him throughout his years with the Toronto Maple Leafs.
The Vegas Golden Knights forward came under heavy criticism after Vegas lost the Stanley Cup Final in six games to the Carolina Hurricanes. Marner finished the postseason with an NHL-leading 29 points in 22 games and looked like a strong Conn Smythe Trophy candidate through the opening three games of the Final. However, his production dried up as Carolina stormed back from a 2-1 series deficit to win the championship.
MORE: Hurricanes coach Rod Brind’Amour reacts after 2026 Stanley Cup win
Speaking on Leafs Morning Take, Matt Larkin noted that Marner’s playoff production has historically dipped in the biggest games.
“Well, it’s crazy. Going into this postseason, his career points per game was something like 1.15. In the playoffs, it was roughly a point per game. In Games 5, 6, and 7 of any series, it was like 0.41,” Larkin said.
Over the final three games, Marner recorded no goals, one assist and a minus-5 rating. SDPN’s Drew Livingstone summed up the frustration, writing: “Mitch Marner 0G | 1A | -5 over the final 3 games of the Stanley Cup Final. All losses. Just folded in crunch time.”
The contrast was striking. Marner produced seven points in the first three games of the series, including a record-setting natural hat trick in Game 3. Once Carolina adjusted defensively and turned to goaltender Brandon Bussi, Vegas struggled to generate offense, and Marner managed only four shots on goal across the final three games.
Familiar questions return for Mitch Marner
The criticism mirrors what Marner often faced during his nine seasons in Toronto. Despite recording 741 points in 657 regular-season games with the Maple Leafs and establishing himself as one of the NHL’s premier playmakers, questions about his playoff performances in elimination and late-series games never fully disappeared.
Former NHLer Jay Rosehill acknowledged Marner’s outstanding postseason overall but noted that the same concerns resurfaced as the Stanley Cup Final slipped away from Vegas.
Larkin offered a balanced but pointed assessment of Marner’s postseason.
“For me, when it comes to Mitch, my slogan this postseason is: all of the things are true,” Larkin said. “Mitch Marner was a great player in Toronto. Mitch Marner disappeared in big moments in Toronto. Mitch Marner was phenomenal in Vegas. Vegas is an easier team to play for. All of the things are true.”
He added, saying, “He was fantastic at both ends of the ice. He was the most dominant player, probably on either team, if you look wire to wire. And he also disappeared when you needed him most. When the going got tough against a really grinding opponent that was more similar to what he faced when he was in deep waters with the Leafs, he did disappear. We have to say it.”
Both realities can exist. Marner drove play for most of the postseason and was central to Vegas reaching the Final. At the same time, elite players are judged by defining moments. Carolina’s structure, led by Jordan Staal and a relentless defensive system, limited Vegas’ top stars when the series tightened.
So, for Marner, the postseason was both a breakthrough and further evidence that he needs to change his playoff reputation in the biggest moments.
About the Author
